DWI Defense

Barrera Defense

TL;DR

You have 15 days to request an ALR hearing to contest a license suspension, or the suspension starts automatically on day 40. Win that hearing and there is no suspension at all.

Do not answer questions about where you are coming from or whether you have had anything to drink. Admitting to a couple of drinks does not get you released. It triggers a full DWI investigation.

You have the right to refuse the roadside field sobriety tests. Whether to agree to a breath or blood test is a local question rather than a blanket rule. In smaller counties, where a judge is not always available to sign a warrant, refusing the breath test can mean law enforcement cannot obtain a blood draw. In San Antonio and Bexar County a judge is always available, and breath test cases tend to be more defensible than blood test cases, so agreeing to the breath test there often makes more sense.

On the license side, a DWI arrest does not automatically mean losing your license. You have 15 days from the day you receive the Notice of Suspension to request an Administrative License Revocation (ALR) hearing to contest it. If you don't request one, the suspension starts automatically on day 40. If your attorney wins that hearing, there is no suspension at all. Most clients are also eligible for an occupational license, which allows continued driving for work, school pickups, and daily life during any suspension period.

Barrera Defense represents people accused of DWI in San Antonio, Floresville, La Vernia, Jourdanton, Pleasanton, Boerne, Poteet, Karnes City, & Kenedy. We challenge the traffic stop, the field sobriety tests, the breath and blood evidence, and the arrest procedures, and keeping a client's life moving is a priority on every DWI case.

Field sobriety tests: what the officer's own training manual says

The roadside tests aren't made up on the spot. Officers are trained to give three Standardized Field Sobriety Tests using a manual published by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), the DWI Detection and Standardized Field Sobriety Test Instructor Guide (2023 edition). That manual sets out exactly how each test is supposed to be given and scored. It's also one of the most useful documents in a DWI defense, because it tells us what the officer was supposed to do.

The three standardized tests

  • Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus (HGN): the "follow the pen with your eyes" test. The officer looks for three clues in each eye, six in all: the eye can't follow the object smoothly, distinct and sustained jerking when the eye is held all the way to the side for at least four seconds, and jerking that starts before the eye reaches 45 degrees. Four or more clues is scored as a likely BAC of 0.08 or higher.
  • Walk and Turn: nine heel-to-toe steps along a line, a turn, and nine steps back. The officer watches for eight clues, such as losing balance during the instructions, starting too soon, stepping off the line, missing heel-to-toe, using arms for balance, an improper turn, or the wrong number of steps. Two or more clues, or not finishing the test, is scored as a BAC of 0.08 or higher.
  • One Leg Stand: one foot about six inches off the ground, counting "one thousand one, one thousand two" for 30 seconds, timed by the officer. The four clues are swaying, using arms for balance, hopping, and putting the foot down. Two or more clues, or not finishing the test, is scored as a likely BAC of 0.08 or higher.

How accurate are field sobriety tests?

By NHTSA's own numbers, from studies using experienced officers, HGN is about 88% accurate, Walk and Turn about 79%, and One Leg Stand about 83% at identifying people at or above 0.08. Put the other way: even when everything is done right, roughly one in eight people is misjudged on the eye test and about one in five on the walking test.

And the manual itself says those numbers only hold up when the tests are given in the standardized way, scored with the standardized clues, and judged by the standardized criteria. In NHTSA's words, "If any one of the SFST elements is changed, the validity may be compromised."

The conditions the manual calls for

The manual sets out conditions and cautions that officers are trained to follow. Among them:

  • The surface. Whenever possible, the walking and balance tests should be done on a reasonably dry, hard, level, non-slippery surface, with enough room for nine heel-to-toe steps. A gravel shoulder at night is not what the research had in mind.
  • The person. The original research found that people over 65, people with back, leg or inner-ear problems, and, for the one leg stand, people 50 or more pounds overweight may have difficulty with the tests. Officers are told to ask about physical problems or disabilities before starting.
  • Shoes. Anyone in heels two inches or higher, flip-flops or other unusual footwear should be offered the chance to take them off.
  • The eye test. The officer is supposed to ask about eyeglasses, check the eyes before starting, and hold the pen 12 to 15 inches from the face and slightly above eye level. When practical, the person should be turned away from flashing lights and passing traffic.
  • The timing. The one leg stand is supposed to be timed for a full 30 seconds. The research found many impaired people can stand on one leg for up to 25 seconds, but few can do it for 30.

Why this matters in your case

Most of the time, there's video. When I review a DWI, I compare what the dash camera and body camera actually show against what the manual requires: where the test was given, what the officer said, how the pen was held, how long the count really ran, and whether anyone asked about your knees, your back or your shoes. When the officer skipped steps or changed the test, the officer's own training materials are what we use to show it.

And remember: in Texas, you can decline the roadside field sobriety tests. They're voluntary.

Field sobriety test questions

Do I have to do field sobriety tests in Texas?
No. The roadside tests are voluntary, and you can politely decline. That's different from the breath or blood test, where refusing leads to a license suspension.

Are field sobriety tests accurate?
According to NHTSA's own research, the three tests are roughly 79% to 88% accurate when given exactly as the training manual requires. Any change to how a test is given or scored may undermine those numbers.

Can a medical condition affect field sobriety tests?
Yes. NHTSA's manual notes that age over 65, back, leg or inner-ear problems, and significant extra weight can make the walking and balance tests difficult, and officers are trained to ask about physical problems first.

Can field sobriety tests be challenged?
Yes. If the tests weren't given in the standardized way, on a suitable surface, or with the required instructions, those problems can be raised in court and at an ALR hearing.

The Statute

Citation: Texas Penal Code §49.04, enhanced by §49.09

Degree and classification

  • Class B misdemeanor for a first offense, with a minimum 72 hours confinement
  • Class A misdemeanor for a BAC of 0.15 or higher or with one prior conviction, minimum 30 days
  • Third-degree felony with two or more priors, or one prior intoxication assault or intoxication manslaughter conviction

Statutory language: A person commits an offense if the person is intoxicated while operating a motor vehicle in a public place.


Other practice areas you may be interested in...

Charges We Fight

Barrera Defense Practice Areas

DWI

A DWI arrest does not automatically cost you your license. You have 15 days to request a hearing to contest it. Barrera Defense defends DWI across…

Drug Cases

Charged with a drug crime? Barrera Defense defends possession, THC vape pen, meth, pill and delivery cases in Bexar, Wilson, Atascosa, Karnes and…

Public Intoxication

The standard is danger to self or others, not simply being intoxicated. Barrera Defense fights public intoxication charges in Bexar, Wilson,…

ALR Hearing

After a DWI arrest in Texas, you have 15 days to request a hearing to fight your license suspension. Miss it, and the suspension starts on day 40.

Credit/Debit Card Abuse

Credit or debit card abuse is a felony at any amount in Texas. Barrera Defense defends card abuse allegations in Bexar, Wilson, Atascosa, Karnes and…

Violation of a Protective Order

Reconciling while an order is in place is still a crime. Barrera Defense defends protective order violations in Bexar, Wilson, Atascosa, Karnes and…

Probation Violations

Accused of violating probation or deferred adjudication in San Antonio or South Texas? Barrera Defense moves fast to protect your freedom.

Escape

Leaving a court-ordered inpatient facility is an escape charge, not just a condition violation. Barrera Defense defends escape cases in San Antonio…

Interference with Child Custody

Refusing to return a child in violation of a court order is a state jail felony. Barrera Defense defends custody interference charges in San Antonio…

Felony DWI

Facing a Felony DWI in San Antonio or South Texas? Barrera Defense challenges the stop, testing procedures, and evidence to protect your future.

Criminal Mischief

Property damage during an argument is a criminal offense in Texas. Barrera Defense defends criminal mischief charges in Bexar, Wilson, Atascosa,…

Manufacture or Delivery of a Controlled Substance

Intent to deliver raises the stakes in a drug case. Barrera Defense defends delivery and intent cases, including fentanyl, in Bexar, Wilson,…

Continuous Sexual Abuse of a Child

Continuous sexual abuse carries 25 to 99 years with no parole eligibility. Barrera Defense defends these allegations in Bexar, Wilson, Atascosa,…

Kidnapping & Unlawful Restraint

Most kidnapping cases are not stranger abductions. Barrera Defense defends restraint and kidnapping allegations across San Antonio and South Texas.

Evading Arrest or Detention

On foot it is a misdemeanor. In a vehicle it is a felony. Barrera Defense defends evading arrest charges across Bexar, Wilson, Atascosa, Karnes and…

Aggravated Assault

Aggravated assault is a second-degree felony in Texas, and first-degree with certain aggravators. Barrera Defense defends these cases in San Antonio…

Manslaughter

Manslaughter turns on recklessness, not intent. Barrera Defense holds the state to exactly what it claims was reckless in Bexar, Wilson, Atascosa,…

Obstruction / Interference with Public Duties

Stepping in to stop a loved one's arrest is itself an offense. Barrera Defense defends interference with public duties charges across San Antonio and…

Indecency with a Child

Indecency with a child is a second-degree felony in Texas. Barrera Defense represents the accused from the investigation stage forward in San Antonio…

Unlawful Carrying of a Weapon

A pistol in the console can add a Class A misdemeanor to a DWI or possession stop. Barrera Defense defends weapons charges across San Antonio and…

Arson

Arson charges in Texas are always felonies and often overlap with insurance fraud allegations. Barrera Defense defends arson cases across San Antonio…

Possession of a Controlled Substance

Possession means care, custody, control or management, and being near drugs is not enough. Barrera Defense defends possession cases in Bexar, Wilson,…

Injury to a Child, Elderly, or Disabled Individual

This statute reaches from a discipline dispute to serious abuse. Barrera Defense defends injury allegations in Bexar, Wilson, Atascosa, Karnes and…

Criminal Trespass

You do not have to be told to leave to be trespassing in Texas. A fence or a posted sign is notice. Barrera Defense defends trespass charges in San…

Disorderly Conduct & Riot

A public fight can bring both an assault charge and a disorderly conduct charge. Barrera Defense defends these cases across San Antonio and South…

Failure to Identify

Giving a relative's name to avoid a warrant can become a felony. Barrera Defense defends failure to identify charges in Bexar, Wilson, Atascosa,…

Deadly Weapon Enhancements

A deadly weapon finding bars regular probation and pushes parole eligibility to half the sentence. Barrera Defense fights these findings in San…

Forgery

Forgery in Texas requires only intent to mislead, not actual gain, and there is no misdemeanor version. Barrera Defense defends forgery charges in…

Deadly Conduct

Deadly conduct does not require anyone to be injured. Barrera Defense defends reckless endangerment and firearm discharge allegations in San Antonio…

Possession of Drug Paraphernalia

Paraphernalia charges often appear when the substance amount is too small to charge. Barrera Defense defends these cases across San Antonio and South…

Juvenile Cases

Barrera Defense represents minors accused of criminal offenses across San Antonio, Floresville, La Vernia, Jourdanton, Pleasanton, Boerne, Poteet,…

Terroristic Threat

A terroristic threat charge can turn on how words were received, not what was meant. Barrera Defense defends these cases in San Antonio and South…

Robbery & Aggravated Robbery

Aggravated robbery is a first-degree felony, the same offense level as murder. Barrera Defense defends robbery charges in Bexar, Wilson, Atascosa,…

Family Violence

Arrested for family violence in Bexar, Wilson, Atascosa, Karnes or Kendall County? There are steps that can be taken in the first 24 hours. Barrera…

Resisting Arrest

Resisting arrest can quickly become assault on a peace officer, a felony. Barrera Defense defends these charges in Bexar, Wilson, Atascosa, Karnes…

THC/Vape Pen Cases

THC vape pens are felonies in Texas, and 2026 changes put delta-8 and THCA products at risk too. Barrera Defense defends THC cases in Bexar, Wilson,…

Murder & Capital Murder

Charged with murder or capital murder in Bexar, Wilson, Atascosa, Karnes or Kendall County? Barrera Defense builds the defense from the first…

Theft

A first theft offense can be a felony in Texas regardless of value. Barrera Defense defends theft and shoplifting charges in Bexar, Wilson, Atascosa,…

DWI with a Child Passenger

A passenger under 15 makes a DWI a state jail felony, even on a first offense. Barrera Defense defends these charges across San Antonio and South…

Possession of a Firearm by a Felon

Gun rights are not restored after five years in Texas. Barrera Defense defends unlawful possession of a firearm charges in Bexar, Wilson, Atascosa,…

Sexual Assault & Aggravated Sexual Assault

Sexual assault allegations require counsel from the first phone call. Barrera Defense represents the accused in Bexar, Wilson, Atascosa, Karnes and…

Assault

Assault causing bodily injury is usually a Class A misdemeanor in Texas, but some cases are charged as felonies. Barrera Defense defends assault…

Fraud & Identity Theft

Identity theft charges often start as petty theft. Barrera Defense defends fraud and identifying information cases in Bexar, Wilson, Atascosa, Karnes…

Burglary

Burglary of a habitation is a second-degree felony carrying two to twenty years. Barrera Defense defends burglary charges across San Antonio and…

Failure to Stop and Render Aid

Leaving an accident scene turns a non-offense into a felony. Barrera Defense defends failure to stop and render aid charges across San Antonio and…